Archive for September, 2009

The “Value” of College

September 28, 2009

   It’s interesting that so many people are openly examining the value of a college degree lately.  The subject seems to be coming up because, in this recession, the most expensive items in the marketplace are ripe for cost-benefit analysis.  Even so, the college degree has so come to be considered “necessary” for success, that it surprises us to even see its value questioned in public.

   But somehow, the value of the degree has become synonymous with its dollar return as compared with its cost.  For many, this is a sufficient answer to the question.  After all, statistics could give us a simple comparison of the lifetime incomes of subjects with different education levels.  And from what I’ve seen, the research overwhelmingly finds that the higher the education, the more people earn.

   What I have not seen, however, is an examination of the underlying assumptions behind the research.  Namely, why is the college degreed job candidate superior to one without the degree for any particular position?  In this regard, what does the research say about why employers will pay a college grad more for a particular job or, more likely, why only college grads will be considered for the job?

   One answer could be, and often is, that the job requires certain skills that form the foundation of knowledge needed to do the job correctly.  I can see that junior engineers, for instance, may need mathematics skills that are  simply not part of the average high school curriculum for basic math literacy.  The employer of a junior engineer has the right to expect applicants to have those skills, and the job description will probably specify them.

   But I never had much skill, or interest, in “technical” stuff.  My bachelors is in the notorious “liberal arts”.  I can tell you that my first job after college — as a welfare caseworker — required absolutely no skills that I acquired in college.  I performed satisfactorily, but I could have done the job just as well right after high school.  And yet, I would not have been considered for the job until I got that degree.

   I think my real question is whether the college degree has another function, one that has nothing to do with what we actually learn there.  Some  commentators have touched on this when they talk of the college grad having value even if he or she was “locked in a closet for four years”.

   Exactly.  And yet, the only serious question today seems to be how expensive it is to get that degree, but not whether we, as a society, place much value on what it offers.



September 24, 2009

This my first posting on WordPress, and I just want to see how it looks.  I’ve been on blogger for a couple of years, and eventually I’ll import the whole collection here.

This blog should connect somehow to my job board website – – but I’ll continue to discuss topics that interest me. Like the law.

Just today, for instance, the NYT had an article about the stipulated settlement of a federal lawsuit against Westchester County which alleged the county’s housing discrimination against minorities.  The county agreed to build hundreds of moderately priced housing units and to promote them “aggressively” to blacks and Hispanics. 

Although this sets no legal precedent – because the county never admitted the charges, and only agreed to the government’s terms to end the lawsuit – the Times has high hopes for it anyway:

     “The settlement could serve as a model for the Obama administration to    challenge the actions of county governments that have resisted pressure to undo decades of patterns of residential segregation.”

     Ha!  Don’t hold your breath.  Based on what we’ve seen so far, do you think that Obama and Holder want to march their forces into that territory?  We’ll see a new constitution in Afghanistan before we get another “settlement” like Westchester!  And the longer they wait, the worse it’s going to look.  You better believe that this “settlement” will be returned to the court when the Justice Department sees how expeditiously these housing units are built.  Let me see…when do they have those local elections again?

%d bloggers like this: